Spindle's End by Robin McKinley
When the queen finally has a child after years of waiting, the rulers want share their joy with everyone and allow one person from every city, town, or village, to the naming ceremony. Katriona represents the little village of Foggy Bottom. The ceremony is interrupted, however, before the twenty-first godparent can give the little princess a gift: the bad fairy Pernicia places a curse on her which will cause her to prick her finger on a spinning wheel and fall into a magical coma. Somehow Kat finds herself carrying the princess home with her. For the next 21 years, Kat and her fairy aunt raise 'Rosie' as their own, hiding her as well as 'ordinariness' can, and hoping that the curse will never come to pass.
This re-telling of Sleeping Beauty is certainly unique. The characters are all well-developed and realistic, as is the magical country where the story takes place. At the same time, this story is incredibly bogged down by McKinley's tendency to describe everything. Particularly at the start of the book, the narrative voice inserts parenthetical comments in nearly every sentence; the end of the book drags on - I almost thought that it would never quite finish. Given this, I would say that this may not be the book for you unless (1) you enjoy re-tellings and want to read them all regardless (and this is an interesting one, I'll admit), or (2) you like very descriptive, somewhat dense books.
Wednesday, October 17, 2007
The Fire Rose by Mercedes Lackey
When her father dies, Rosalind Hawkins is left with debt and few options. A professor of hers mentions a letter he has received from a man in San Francisco looking for a tutor/governess for his children, but requires particular language skills. As a scholar and doctoral student, Rose has the necessary qualifications and she decides to leave what is left of her life in Chicago to start a new one on the West Coast. She discovers when she arrives that there are no children, but that her position may actually be better than she had hoped.
I absolutely love these re-tellings of fairy tales that Mercedes Lackey does; the books are historical and put Magick in the 'real world' to create 'realistic' ways for fairy tale stories to come about. This one tells the story of Beauty and the Beast with realistic characters and an interesting plot. Although this bears no resemblance to the 'original' it is definitely the same story.
I need to give a brief explanation about where this book falls in the series so that it makes sense. This book is not listed among those of the Elemental Masters series [The Serpent's Shadow (Snow White and the Seven Dwarves), The Gates of Sleep (Sleeping Beauty), Phoenix and Ashes (Cinderella), The Wizard of London (The Snow Queen), and Reserved for the Cat (Puss in Boots)] presumably because all of the books in the series take place in England around the same time and the later books reference characters from the early ones. However, I think that this one still belongs at the head of the series in part because it gives a more thorough introduction to the 'Magickal' world than the others do. I don't think readers would be confused by not reading this one first, but I do think it helps.
I definitely recommend this book to fantasy fans, particularly those who like re-tellings or stories about magic in the 'real world'/historical fantasy.
When her father dies, Rosalind Hawkins is left with debt and few options. A professor of hers mentions a letter he has received from a man in San Francisco looking for a tutor/governess for his children, but requires particular language skills. As a scholar and doctoral student, Rose has the necessary qualifications and she decides to leave what is left of her life in Chicago to start a new one on the West Coast. She discovers when she arrives that there are no children, but that her position may actually be better than she had hoped.
I absolutely love these re-tellings of fairy tales that Mercedes Lackey does; the books are historical and put Magick in the 'real world' to create 'realistic' ways for fairy tale stories to come about. This one tells the story of Beauty and the Beast with realistic characters and an interesting plot. Although this bears no resemblance to the 'original' it is definitely the same story.
I need to give a brief explanation about where this book falls in the series so that it makes sense. This book is not listed among those of the Elemental Masters series [The Serpent's Shadow (Snow White and the Seven Dwarves), The Gates of Sleep (Sleeping Beauty), Phoenix and Ashes (Cinderella), The Wizard of London (The Snow Queen), and Reserved for the Cat (Puss in Boots)] presumably because all of the books in the series take place in England around the same time and the later books reference characters from the early ones. However, I think that this one still belongs at the head of the series in part because it gives a more thorough introduction to the 'Magickal' world than the others do. I don't think readers would be confused by not reading this one first, but I do think it helps.
I definitely recommend this book to fantasy fans, particularly those who like re-tellings or stories about magic in the 'real world'/historical fantasy.
- If this book sounds interesting, consider these: Beauty & Rose Daughter, The Fairy's Return and Other Princess Stories, or Wicked Lovely
Erec Rex: The Dragon Eye by Kaza Kingsley
Erec Rex is a twelve-year-old boy living in an unconventional family with his 'mother,' June, who has adopted him and five other children. Erec himself is a bit unusual - he has a glass eye and occasionally experiences compulsions which force him to do things that help people. His life changes forever when one of these 'cloudy thoughts' compels him to go searching for his mother. He meets Bethany, a neglected child subject to her uncle's whims, and she helps him to enter a secret, magical world where his mother has been taken. They get swept up into 'Alypium' where children are competing to be the next three rulers of the magical realm (the current triplets, two kings and a queen, have decided to retire after 500 years and the royal triplets born to King Piter died as children). Between trying to rescue his mother and competing against several hundred youths who know more about their world than he does, Erec finds his hands full and has to scramble to keep on top of it all.
Honestly, I'm not really a fan of this book. The plot is vaguely interesting and new but the writing doesn't do it justice. It starts out with so much happening that I couldn't get my bearings for the first couple of chapters (and I never did catch on to the way that they were naming places). The characters are fairly realistic, but a lot of the development feels forced. In particular, the the dialog feels contrived and unnatural and repetitive in some cases (Erec's conversations with his mother are all the same). Besides that, most fantasy fans will guess the gist of the outcome from his name/the title (I don't think I'm giving anything away by saying that). Generally speaking, I'd have to say that there is a lot of fantasy out there worth reading and if you skip this series, you aren't missing much; consider these instead:
Erec Rex is a twelve-year-old boy living in an unconventional family with his 'mother,' June, who has adopted him and five other children. Erec himself is a bit unusual - he has a glass eye and occasionally experiences compulsions which force him to do things that help people. His life changes forever when one of these 'cloudy thoughts' compels him to go searching for his mother. He meets Bethany, a neglected child subject to her uncle's whims, and she helps him to enter a secret, magical world where his mother has been taken. They get swept up into 'Alypium' where children are competing to be the next three rulers of the magical realm (the current triplets, two kings and a queen, have decided to retire after 500 years and the royal triplets born to King Piter died as children). Between trying to rescue his mother and competing against several hundred youths who know more about their world than he does, Erec finds his hands full and has to scramble to keep on top of it all.
Honestly, I'm not really a fan of this book. The plot is vaguely interesting and new but the writing doesn't do it justice. It starts out with so much happening that I couldn't get my bearings for the first couple of chapters (and I never did catch on to the way that they were naming places). The characters are fairly realistic, but a lot of the development feels forced. In particular, the the dialog feels contrived and unnatural and repetitive in some cases (Erec's conversations with his mother are all the same). Besides that, most fantasy fans will guess the gist of the outcome from his name/the title (I don't think I'm giving anything away by saying that). Generally speaking, I'd have to say that there is a lot of fantasy out there worth reading and if you skip this series, you aren't missing much; consider these instead:
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)