Friday, June 20, 2008

The Magic and the Healing by Nick O'Donohoe

BJ Vaughan is having a rough time - her mother's recent suicide has disrupted her concentration and, even though she's almost done with vet school, she isn't sure that she'll be able to finish. Her perspectives begin to change when one of the professors invites her to join a selective large animal rotation. In the class, she and her fellow students are introduced to Crossroads, a parallel world that intersects the 'real world' where the veterinary students encounter challenges that they had never imagined. They must learn to practice medicine with little access to information on the physiology or treatment of unicorns, griffins, or centaurs, among others. As each of the students discovers that the world is a bit larger than they believed, BJ must face her fears and discover whether or not she is willing to accept a new view on her own reality.

Unlike most fantasy books, this one is very strongly rooted in reality - the experiences of the students are told with explicit description of veterinary examinations and procedures. At the same time, the book is about the people as much as it is about the medicine. The story focuses primarily on BJ and her struggle to make difficult decisions in her life, although, personally I didn't feel all that sympathetic even though her character is well developed. Perhaps this is partly because some elements of the story seemed predictable, even from the start. The narration of the story actually switches between the students and the king of Crossroads (Brandal) which is a little confusing at times and is never entirely resolved even at the end of the book. Overall, even though the book had some issues, they were relatively minor and didn't detract from the story. I would still recommend this book to readers, especially those who enjoy 'real world' fantasy books.


Reserved for the Cat by Mercedes Lackey

Ninette Dupond has just lost her job with the Paris Opera Ballet because she performed a piece just a little too well for the tastes of one of the prima ballerinas. With limited options, she is just about to give up on finding a new position when a cat shows up at her apartment and speaks to her, convincing her to pack her things and travel to England. Soon she is wrapped up in a scheme pretending to be a Russian ballerina and performing again in an English theater. Her new life seems a little too good to be true, however, and little does she know that an elemental spirit has devoured the real ballerina that she's impersonating and the elemental has found out about Ninette's deception and has decided to remove the competition.

This is the most recent book in the Elemental Master's series (The Serpent's Shadow, The Gates of Sleep, Phoenix and Ashes, The Wizard of London), but it seems to work more as a stand-alone than as a continuation that some of the other books maintain. I enjoyed this book well enough although I didn't feel that it was one of the best in the series. The characters are very well developed and the plot is interesting without being too predictable. I would definitely recommend this book to fantasy readers, especially those who enjoy historical fiction and fantasy books that involve magic in the 'real world.'


Dragonhaven by Robin McKinley

Jake has spent his entire life at the Makepeace Institute which protects Smokehill National Park - one of the largest dragon preserves in the world. He has had an unconventional upbringing as the son of two professors, but he has enjoyed living at the park. Jake's mother died when he was young, in a mysterious accident at the park and shortly after, his dog died as well, leaving him very much alone. Those experiences have shaped Jake's life as he prepares for his first overnight excursion in the Park. But when something entirely unexpected happens that night, Jake's life is going to be irreparably changed and force him to grow up far more quickly than he expected.

This book is rather typical of McKinley's style, told in a roundabout way using first person; it was very slow in the start and felt a bit dense and wordy, but picked up a few chapters in. Once I got to the main part of the story, I enjoyed reading it. The characters are a little fuzzy in their development, but not enough to detract from the story and the plot in certainly different than the usual novel. Overall, I enjoyed reading Dragonhaven and I'd recommend it to fantasy fans.


Stravaganza: City of Masks by Mary Hoffman

Lucien is a young boy with cancer, struggling through his most recent treatment. His father gives him a blank book with a strange design on the cover so that he'll have someplace to write his thoughts. Something strange happens when Lucien falls asleep holding it, though - he finds himself in a place called 'Belleza' which seems very like old Venice but with important differences. Lucien discovers from the people there that he is a 'Stravagante,' meaning that he can travel between his world and that of Belleza. Although it starts as a fun adventure, his trips begin to cause complications at home, and things become more dangerous in Belleza; will Lucien be able to keep up his double life without everything falling apart?

First of all, I should point out that this book is written by a British author and takes a little getting used to for anyone who reads primarily American English books. Otherwise, the story is interesting and the characters are fairly well-crafted, but I definitely felt that there were some issues. Parts of the book made little sense and, in some cases the logic was explained after the fact, but I really could not accept some of the claims that were central to the plot. Also, the whole story seemed unsophisticated and the ending of the book appears to reconcile all of the loose ends, but I didn't think that it worked quite as well as it is meant to. This book is actually the first of three: Stravaganza: City of Stars, and Stravaganza: City of Flowers but I was not impressed enough with the first to continue reading the series. In general, I would say that this book wasn't bad for a light, 'fluffy' read if the subject sounds appealing, but I don't recommend it as one that I really enjoyed; consider these instead: